Uniswap vs PancakeSwap

9 months ago

What Is PancakeSwap?

PancakeSwap is a DEX powered by the Binance Smart Chain (BSC), which uses an automated market maker (AMM) model to fulfill orders. As such, PancakeSwap replaces an order book with a liquidity pool.

As of September 2021, PancakeSwap claims to be the most popular decentralized platform, with over 2.8 million users and $9.9 billion in total value locked (TVL). The latest version is PancakeSwap V2, and there are 1,426 token pairs to trade on the DEX.

Liquidity providers interact with PancakeSwap's Syrup Pools and receive LP tokens (called FLIP) that represent their share in the pool. These tokens are key to removing their share from the pool. Users can also farm for two additional tokens — CAKE and SYRUP. Since the platform runs on BSC, the tokens adhere to the platform's BEP-20 token standards.

True to its vibrant and almost playful nature, PancakeSwap also offer on-chain games. Users can participate in price prediction of BNB (currently in Beta) or enter into the lottery to win prizes in BNB.

Furthermore, the LP tokens come in different “flavors” influenced by the token deposited in the pool.

What Is Uniswap?

Uniswap is the most popular Ethereum-based DEX that uses an AMM model, employs liquidity pools instead of order books and has LP tokens for liquidity providers. Uniswap is the mother chain of PancakeSwap, which uses the original Ethereum blockchain to run its network as opposed to BSC. As one of the first wildly successful DeFi protocols, most DEXs have, in one way or another, borrowed features from Uniswap to run their own platforms.

Note that the AMM model removes the need to have a partner on the other side of a buy or sell order for a trade to go through. Consequently, less trading time is consumed on DEXs using this model. By removing the need to go through know-your-customer (KYC) procedures, these exchanges give access to decentralized token swapping to more people.

As of September 2021, Uniswap has over $6.3 billion in TVL. The protocol boasts over 1.5 million all-time users, and $386 billion in trade volume. The latest version of the protocol is Uniswap V3, which launched on the mainnet in May 2021.

Why The Rivalry Between PancakeSwap and Uniswap?

After an incredible 2020 DeFi summer, in which it rewrote the rules for decentralized exchanges, Uniswap has been viewed as a benchmark for DEXs, considering that most DeFi-focused projects are trying to take up the mantle in becoming the leading platform for token swaps.

PancakeSwap is the unofficial winner to this war, with its liquidity increasing by over 1,000% in approximately two months. Furthermore, PancakeSwap's volume had skyrocketed from a meager $37 million to a “whopping” $1 billion within the first 49 days of 2021.

Interestingly, its growth has been attributed to the shortcomings of the Ethereum blockchain that hosts Uniswap. The ETH-powered network suffers from scalability issues due to its reliance on the proof-of-work (PoW) consensus mechanism. As a result, the congestion on the platform causes a rise in transaction costs or gas.

In December 2020, Ethereum started the migration from a PoW to a PoS (proof-of-stake) consensus mechanism through the launch of Ethereum 2.0, which is expected to solve the scalability issue. Unfortunately, the complete rollout is expected to take approximately two years.

Why Binance Smart Chain?

Binance Smart Chain continues to gain more foothold in the DeFi space. Some of the key areas BSC succeeds at include:

Efficiency and Affordability

Instead of a PoW system, it uses a version of PoS called proof-of-staked-authority (PoSA). This version provides a three-second block time, which means that transactions settle faster and fees are substantially lower since there is no network congestion.

Inter-Blockchain Compatibility

BSC is compatible with other decentralized platforms. For example, BSC is compatible with Ethereum because it supports the Ethereum Virtual Machine (EVM). This means that Ethereum developers can quickly transfer (port) their projects to Binance by turning a few nobs, so to speak.

PancakeSwap Flippens Uniswap

In February 2021, PancakeSwap had briefly usurped Uniswap as the largest AMM-based exchange. The daily trading volume on the BSC-powered project DEX was over $400 million more than the ETH-based platform on February 19.

Notably, the rise had been steady, recording over $1 billion in volume per day. Ethereum recorded $16 million in gas fees in a single day, while BSC users only had to pay a tiny fraction of that sum.

However, as of September 2021, Uniswap had regained its place above PancakeSwap — but a new player, Biswap, has already taken the number one spot above Uniswap, showing just how fast the decentralized trading world moves.

While Uniswap and PancakeSwap have 24H trading volumes over $1 billion, it still falls behind the top centralized exchanges (CEXs). For instance, the largest cryptocurrency exchange in the world, Binance, has 24H trading volume over $34 billion, at the time of this writing on Sept. 10, 2021.

PancakeSwap vs. Uniswap: Top DEXs Compared

PancakeSwap Native Token — CAKE

CAKE is PancakeSwap's base asset, which doubles as a governance token, as well as provides farming and staking functionalities. Users can get their hands on CAKE by either providing liquidity, staking or buying them on an exchange (the staking option allows holders to earn more tokens).

Note that CAKE tokens issued to liquidity providers are tradable on the open crypto market, just like standard coins.

The exchange’s CAKE token had also recorded significant growth, gaining over 2,964% since the start of 2021.

Uniswap Native Token — UNI

On the other hand, we have UNI tokens, Uniswap’s native asset, which its developers had airdropped to initial users of its platform back in September 2020. However, the token's real use case on the platform, apart from governance, is yet to be defined.

As such, by the time UNI’s use case is more clarified, if it ever is, CAKE is expected to have gained more traction. For other governance purposes, PancakeSwap has another token called SYRUP, which allows holders to receive 40% of CAKE emissions — Syrup is not designed to be sold, since it is needed to unstake any staked CAKE

Adoption Rate

It's hard to quantify the two top DEXs on this one. While PancakeSwap's adoption rate is on the rise, Uniswap is older and has a considerable user base. It's among the few projects that fished DeFi from the shadows by introducing AMM functionalities that no other project had successfully executed before.

However, PancakeSwap seems to be on its way to pass Uniswap, owing to the rise in adoption of both the Binance Smart Chain and the CAKE token. As is common in the crypto space, the price of a digital asset responds to adoption or at least demand.

PancakeSwap has more active users than Uniswap, however the trading volume of Uniswap is higher, suggesting that Uniswap users are trading in larger denominations.

Transaction Costs

Ethereum clearly lost the battle on transaction costs at the moment, leaving the door wide open for more efficient platforms with smart contract capability. With Uniswap running on the second-largest blockchain, gas fees have been exponentially rising.

The problem is even bigger for Uniswap users who can only trade small amounts, as the gas costs would eat into their profits. By using a scalable network like BSC, PancakeSwap is able to offer dramatically lower transaction costs.

On BSC, transaction costs are in terms of pennies compared to Ethereum, whose fees can go up to a few hundred dollars. Apart from saving users from high gas fees, BSC also facilitates faster transactions.

Number of Listed Tokens

PancakeSwap has the edge here, especially given the explosion of meme tokens on BSC. As of September 2021, PancakeSwap (V2) has 1427 tokens, compared to Uniswap (V3) which has 599.

However, in September 2020, the speed and sheer number of tokens listed on the network raised eyebrows as Uniswap reported an average of 150 token pairs added a day for a whole seven days — while an open system drives freedom, this freedom also extends to malicious actors. As a result of Uniswap’s permissionless system, fake projects had surged, eager to cash in on hasty investors. For example, Uniswap saw the listing of "Uniswap Exchange Token," which had no relation at all to Uniswap besides being listed on the platform.

PancakeSwap boasts the listing of successful and unique tokens like FRONT and BAKE — but the same “low-quality listing” issue that plagues Uniswap is also existent in the BSC-based fork.

Hence, the number of listed tokens may not necessarily mean the DEX is better, as it could be attributed to more meme tokens or even scam tokens being listed. In fact, quality over quantity is very true in this case, and the stringent vetting process of CEXs may be an advantage in this area.

Liquidity and Trading Volume

Although the liquidity on PancakeSwap is on the rise, Uniswap is still leading. Most tokens on Uniswap have substantial liquidity compared to those on PancakeSwap. More liquidity providers prefer Uniswap since PancakeSwap's liquidity provision incentives favor those that deposit exotic tokens that are the most volatile.

9 comments